Church History and Archives

Our History

Gathered by the English Puritan settlers of Massachusetts Bay Colony in August of 1629, The First Church in Salem is one of the oldest churches organized in North America and the first to be governed by congregational polity.* During its long history the theological position of the Church has changed, most significantly in the early 1800's when Unitarianism was embraced.


Starting in 1718, the Church itself broke into five different churches, with all but one rejoining the original First Church in later years. Today, the congregation worships at the meetinghouse of the North Church, built in 1836. The one congregation that remains independent is the Tabernacle Church in Salem, which separated from the First Church in 1734 over a row about a minister at the time.


The present church edifice (dedicated in 1836) is the second Meeting House of the North Church which separated from the First Church in 1772 and reunited with it in 1923. It is early English Gothic style in design and is constructed of Quincy granite. The First Church in Salem has been responsible for several of the well known landmarks within the town of Salem including the Daniel Lowe Building on Washington Street (the meetinghouse for the First Church up until 1923 when they merged with the North Church) and the Witch Museum on Salem Common (the meetinghouse for the Second Church in Salem which split from the First Church in 1719 and reunited with it in 1956).

For a longer version of our history, click here.


(* Note: The other two churches that date back to this period or before are the Marble Collegiate Church in New York City and the First Church in Plymouth, Massachusetts).

First Church History Page Highlights

Our Meetinghouse

The present church edifice (dedicated in 1836) is the second Meeting House of the North Church which separated from the First Church in 1772 and reunited with it in 1923. It is early English Gothic style in design and is constructed of Quincy granite. The First Church in Salem has been responsible for several of the well known landmarks within the town of Salem including the Daniel Lowe Building on Washington Street (the meetinghouse for the First Church up until 1923 when they merged with the North Church) and the Witch Museum on Salem Common (the meetinghouse for the Second Church in Salem which split from the First Church in 1719 and reunited with it in 1956).

Separations and Mergers

The First Church 1629-Present
The North Church 1772-1923
The East Church 1719-1899
The Barton Square Church 1824-1899
The Second Church 1899-1956
   
In 1772, the North Church separated from the First Church.
In 1719, the East Church separated from the First Church.
In 1824, the Barton Square Church separated from the First Church.
In 1899, the East Church and the Barton Square Church merged to form the Second Church.
In 1923, the North Church and Second Church reunited with the First Church.

First Church Succession of Ministers

1629 Francis Higginson 1630
1629 Samuel Skelton 1634
1635 Roger Williams 1635
1636 Hugh Peter 1641
1640 Edward Norris 1658
1660 John Higginson 1708
1660 Nicholas Noyes 1717
1714 George Curwen 1717
1718 Samuel Fiske 1735
1736 John Sparhawk 1755
1755 Thomas Barnard 1776
1772 Asa Dunbar 1779
1779 John Prince 1836
1824 Charles Wentworth Upham 1844
1846 Thomas Treadwell Stone 1852
1853 George Ware Briggs 1867
1868 James Tracy Hewes 1875
1877 Fielder Israel 1889
1890 George Croswell Cressey 1896
1897 Elvin James Prescott 1902
1903 Peter Hair Goldsmith 1910
1911 Edward Dunbar Johnson 1921
1923 Theodore Davenport Bacon  1924
1925 Thomas Henry Billings 1934
1935 Bradford Eugene Gale 1958
1959 John Kohlsaat Hammon 1964
1965 Ronald Michael Mazur 1970
1970 Robert William Cummings 1977
1978 John Richard Bernard Szala 1991
1994 Kenneth A. Clarke 1997
1997 Jeffrey Philip Snell  
     

North Church Succession of Ministers

1772 Thomas Barnard, Jr. 1814
1815 John Emery Abbott 1819
1820 John Brazer 1846
1847 Octavius Brooks Frothingham 1855
1855 Charles Lowe 1857
1859 Edmund Burke Willson 1895
1893 George Dimmick Latimer  1907
1907 Theodore Davenport Bacon 1923
     

East Church Succession of Ministers

1719 Robert Stanton 1727
1728 William Jennison 1737
1737 James Diman 1788
1783 William Bentley 1819
1821 James Flint 1855
1851 Dexter Clapp 1864
1865 Samuel C. Beane 1878
1879 George Herbert Hosmer 1886
1886 William Henry Ramsay 1888
1892 Edward D. Towle 1897
     

Barton Square Church Succession of Ministers

1824 Henry Colman 1831
1831 James W. Thompson 1859
1862 A. M. Haskell 1866
1866 George Batchelor 1882
1883 Benjamin F. McDaniel 1886
1887 F. B. Mott 1891
1893 Alfred Manchester 1899
     

The Second Church Succession of Ministers

1899 Alfred Manchester 1926
1927 James Luther Adams 1934
1934 Duncan Howlett 1938
1938 Frank B. Crandall 1953
1953 Edmond Ayers 1955
     

Prominent Parishioners

Samuel Skelton The Church's first pastor (1629-1634).
Francis Higginson The author of the Church's Covenant and its first teacher (1629-1630)
Roger Williams Founder of the First Baptist Church in America; third minister of this church in 1635.
Hugh Peter The Church's fourth minister (1636-1641) return to England and became chaplain to Oliver Cromwell and was hanged, drawn and quartered for complicity in the death of King Charles I.
Rebecca Nurse and Giles Cory Two of the victims of the witchcraft hysteria of 1692, were members of this Church.
    

Other notables include:

Nathaniel Hawthorne And the Hawthorne family
Jones Very Transcendentalist
Lincoln F. Bingham Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Massachusetts
Arthur Foote Composer
Edward Sylvester Morse Biologist and authority on Japanese culture
Nathaniel Peabody Father of the Peabody sisters: Sophia Peabody Hawthorne, Mary Peabody Mann, and Elizabeth Palmer Peabody.
Leverett Saltonstall First mayor of Salem
Charles Dexter Cleveland American Consul at Cardiff
Henry K. Oliver Organist and composer